Papa Kelsey's Menu (Updated September 2025)

Introducing the Menu at Papa Kelsey's

Welcome to Papa Kelsey's, a beloved pizza and sub restaurant located in Twin Falls, Idaho, where culinary passion meets community spirit. The moment you step into the cozy atmosphere, the enticing aroma of freshly baked dough and subs whisks you away. With a menu that caters to every palate, you'll find far more than just pizza.

  • Subs: The subs here are nothing short of legendary. Favorites such as the Southwest Chipotle Chicken and the Italian combo capture the essence of comfort food, featuring tender meats and vibrant veggies complemented by perfectly melted cheese.
  • Desserts: Don't overlook the cinnamon roll—this fluffy pastry swirled with rich cinnamon butter and topped with sweet glaze is a crowd-pleaser that beckons you after your meal.
  • Kid's Menu: Families will appreciate the kid-friendly choices, including personal pizzas and chicken nuggets, ensuring a delightful dining experience for everyone.

Whether you're a long-time local or just passing through, the warm service and generous portions promise to create lasting memories. Papa Kelsey’s isn’t just a meal; it’s an experience to savor.

Extra Menu Picks